11 Tips for Renting a Beach House (Lessons I Learned the Hard Way)

Cathy Bennett Kopf Avatar
oceanfront beach house rental in the Outer Banks
Photo credit: Cathy Bennett Kopf

Renting a beach house this summer? It’s a wonderful way to spend your family vacation, whether you go for two weeks or a long weekend. But there are lots of decisions to make: Where will you go? Rent through VRBO, a local agency or by owner? Is a beachfront house worth the splurge?

As the designated “renter-in-chief” for my family, I’ve spent years planning beach house vacations. I’ve booked beautiful oceanfront rentals and a couple of memorable duds. After decades of family beach trips, I’ve learned exactly what makes a rental house perfect and what mistakes to avoid. These 11 tips for renting a beach house will help you choose a place where your family can relax, reconnect and make lasting vacation memories.

Key Takeaways:

  • Book early. Many popular beach rentals are reserved months in advance, often starting in the fall for the following summer.
  • Choose your location carefully. There’s a big difference between a 5-minute walk to the beach and a 5-minute drive. Factor in the convenience of a beach rental steps from the sand, especially when traveling with family members who tire easily like toddlers and grands.
  • Make a list of must-have features. Think about bedroom arrangements, parking, accessibility and other essentials for your group. A pool is a non-negotiable for my family.
  • Read listings carefully. Check maps and guest reviews to confirm the home matches the description. No one likes surprises. Especially unpleasant ones.
  • Consider shoulder season. Booking just before or after peak summer weeks can mean lower prices and fewer crowds.

Beach House Vacations Make Lasting Family Memories

Okay. You’ve decided to take a family beach vacation this year. Booking one or more hotel rooms is pretty easy to do. But, if you’re looking to have everyone gather together – ‘round a big kitchen island for breakfast, on shady chaise lounges for post-beach naps or atop the roof at sunset – then you’ll want to rent a beach house.

The vacations when we’ve rented beach houses rank right at the tippy top of our favorite family trips. Everyone has their treasured memories. I can still feel the wind on my face and the joy in my sister’s smile when we flew our first kites on the beach in front of our Outer Banks, North Carolina, rental house.

My son will never forget the time he found a snake in his bed.

It may have made him scream at the time, but we laugh about it every time someone starts singing “Snake in the bed! Snake in the bed!”

Are you ready to explore more? Let us inspire you!

When Should You Book a Beach House Rental?

caribbean sunset with a private beach house pool
When it’s time to splurge, an infinity pool with a sunset view is hard to beat. Photo credit: Cathy Bennett Kopf

You know when I start getting emails from real estate agents about summer beach rentals? October. Usually, I haven’t even bought a pumpkin yet. Is it really time to start thinking about my summer beach vacation?

The answer is “yes.”

When planning to rent a house in a popular beach destination, like Surf City NC, next summer, fall is the perfect time to book it. Good houses disappear quickly. If you wait too long, the best houses will already be taken and you might get stuck with a beach rental that’s less than prime.

Is it too late to book one for this summer? Heck no! But you need to get moving…NOW!

Follow these 11 tips to rent the beach house that will make your family thank you…for a full week!

1. Research Your Beach House Location

A luxury beachfront rental on Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. Photo Credit: Beach House Boutique
A luxury beachfront rental on Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. Photo credit: Beach House Boutique

The first thing to do is to choose your beach house destination.

Maybe you go to the same beach town every year. When I was a kid, we went to Cape Cod every year. In that case, you know the neighborhoods, the restaurants and where to find the yummiest ice cream (Day’s Ice Cream in Ocean Grove, New Jersey, is a personal fave!). You’ll have an easy time finding a beach house in a location that suits your family.

But, maybe you’re heading to a beach you’ve never visited before. One year we decided to give the Outer Banks in North Carolina a try for our summer vacation. Friends raved about it.

You know who I went to for info before renting a beach house? Those friends of mine. I quizzed them incessantly about the different beach neighborhoods, where to buy the most colorful kites and which restaurants would accept walk-in groups of 12 for dinner.

2. How Much Does it Cost to Rent a Beach House?

A luxe lanai overlooking the pool? Yes, please! Photo credit: Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

A weekly beach house rental can cost as little as a few hundred dollars to as much as a car. A really nice car. The price depends on several factors:

  • Beach houses in uber popular destinations like Delaware’s Rehoboth Beach command top dollar.
  • Beach house weekly rentals max out during the prime summer months.
  • The closer you are to the water, the more you’ll pay for your beautiful beach house, especially if it is an oceanfront listing.
  • A one bed/one bath cottage will always be cheaper than a 6 bed/8 bath mansion.
  • High end amenities like a private pool, elevator and theater room will add $$ to your weekly rental fee.

Set a budget and (try) to stick to it. In my experience, renting a beach house is cheaper than renting multiple hotel rooms. We generally travel as a pack of 10. Five rooms at a nice beach resort in high season can run $2000 a night.

Having access to a kitchen saves us money too. We eat breakfast in our beach house and pack lunches for the beach. It’s another way to save money.

The key to not blowing your vacation house rental budget is to clearly define your essential house features and the high-end add-ons you might consider.

3. Make a List of Vacation Rental Must-Haves

king size bed draped with mosquito netting in caribbean beach house
Forget bunk beds and pull-out couches. The master bedroom in our beach house better have a king-size bed. Ocean view preferred. Photo credit: Cathy Bennett Kopf

Consider the group that will be staying in your beach house and compile a list of non-negotiable items. For example, the first thing I look for in a listing is at least one bedroom with a king bed for me and hubby. It’s our vacation and I’m not cramming into a queen, no matter how nice the house.

If Granny’s coming and she has trouble with stairs, you’ll need an elevator or a one-story. Off-street parking is another must, especially if your group has multiple cars. Many beach towns restrict street parking to residents only.

Once you have your list of essential features, it’s time to dream about fancy upgrades like a hot tub or rooftop deck.

4. Dream Big! Consider a Beach House Luxury Feature

private beach walkway with sun shining
Private beach access is a luxury feature to consider when checking out beach rental listings. Photo credit: Cathy Bennett Kopf

Once you have a list of what you need, consider indulging in what you want.

Maybe it’s a beachfront porch with a sunset view. Or a fire pit for making s’mores at night. A pool table will keep the teens busy if (when) it rains at the beach. A plunge pool is super for quick dips between trips to the beach.

If you can dream it, there’s a beach house that has it. Just remember – those high-end features come at a price. Remember your budget and be on the lookout for deals that look too good to be true.

5. Use Caution if Working Directly with the Owner

I’ve booked vacation rentals directly, using Airbnb and VRBO. And I’ve worked with professional rental agents. I’ll give you the pros and cons of both.

The one piece of advice I’ll give you is to tune out public opinion advising you to rent directly from owners to save money.

Case in point. Last summer, I asked a co-worker who owns a summer beach rental at the Jersey Shore if he had availability for the 4th of July weekend. He did and we settled on an extremely low price – a “friends and family” discount.

We have a dog; I asked if we could bring him. The owner said we could. He assured me the unit was pet-friendly. At the last minute, we decided to board our pup.

And it’s a good thing we did. The house was filled to the brim with breakable objects. Our furry fellow would have trashed the place. A rental agent would have steered me to a different location.

6. Real Estate Agents are Beach House Pros

When your beach house rental screams “Welcome Home!”, you know you chose wisely. Photo credit: Historic Key West Vacation Rentals

Using an experienced agent, especially if you’re unfamiliar with the beach town, can be the smartest decision you make. If you clearly list your wants and needs, a good agent will pick a spot that suits you perfectly. It’s the equivalent of hiring a personal shopper to put together the right outfit. It may cost more, but it’s worth it.

The process works even better if you can meet the agent in person and tour properties in advance.

7. Check Out Potential Vacation Rentals in Person, When Possible

Sunset on Tybee Island, a destination with excellent family-friendly summer beach house rentals.
Put on a light jacket and hang out on a restaurant deck to watch a fall beach sunset. Photo credit: Cathy Bennett Kopf

The primary reason I like working with a real estate agent when choosing a summer beach house is that they can give you tours of the houses if you visit in person. This works particularly well when you head to the beach in the off-season.

I recommend heading to the beach you’re considering for your summer vacation in the fall and booking your rental on the spot. Autumn is a great time to head to the beach. Tourists are nearly extinct. There are no waiting lines for restaurants and the locals are happy to tell you why they love their slice of paradise. The sunsets are as beautiful as those in July. You can’t swim in the ocean, but, hey, no sand in your shorts. Lose some. Win some.

And I recommend you go solo on the reconnaissance trip. You’ll move quicker and you won’t be hampered by the kids whining that the vacation rental you think is perfect is too far from the beach. Or listening to your husband complain that the 65″ TV is too small.

8. Online Listings: What to Look for Beyond the Photos

blue, green and pink cottage bed in a Tybee Island beach house rental
I don’t know that I would have discovered this charming Tybee Island cottage without the help of a professional real estate agent. Photo credit: Cathy Bennett Kopf

Although I enjoy working with professional rental agents, I also have rented summer beach houses online. Airbnb, VRBO and other 3rd party sites are filled with houses ripped from the pages of Coastal Living magazine. One’s prettier than the next and every one seems to have a sunset water view.

But they don’t.

Here’s what to look for in an online listing to get a more realistic picture of potential rental homes.

  • Check the map to see how close the house is to the beach and the grocery store, restaurants and other amenities.
  • Read the reviews. Be particularly wary of noise complaints and unresponsive owners.
  • Count the beds and bodies. Twice. Your 10-year old won’t mind a sofa bed in the loft. My 25-year old? Uh. No.

9. Consider Shoulder Season for Vacation Rental Savings

Beach house rental prices are highest during peak summer months. That varies by location. Houses along east coast beaches, will be most expensive during July and August. Check out prices during that time in New York’s Hamptons. You’ll swoon! But beach house rentals in Florida might be a bargain in mid-summer.

If you have any flexibility to your travel schedule, try to book your beach home for a week before or immediately after the prime season. You’ll get a lower rental rate and it will be less crowded but the weather is likely to be just as beautiful. The same beach weather, but a shorter wait in line for an ice cream sundae? Win-win!

10. Check the Fine Print in the Rental Contract

Sure. It’s a lot of words crammed onto too many pages. But there’s a ton of information included in your summer rental contract. Cindy Carter of Historic Key West Vacation Rentals says that the primary reason there’s a disconnect between an agency and a client is because the client hasn’t read the agency’s cancellation policy.

Be sure to read the rental contract before signing. The whole thing. Some items to look for include:

  • Check the dates…twice. Most weeklong rentals go Saturday to Saturday or Sunday to Sunday. You want to make sure you arrive on the right day.
  • Be sure you’re clear on whether linens are included or not. It would be a tremendous drag to have to head to Target to buy a bunch of sheets and towels.
  • Make sure you understand the cancellation policy. Stuff happens. Sometimes you might lose a deposit if you cancel; other rentals might demand 50%. Consider travel insurance if you’re risking a lot of money.

11. Don’t Have Second Thoughts

Renter’s remorse is a real thing. The minute you commit to a vacation home rental, you’ll come across 7 others you wish you’d booked.

In the words of Disney’s Princess Elsa: let it go.

You will have a good time, even if the house doesn’t check every box on your list. We arrived at one rental to find it dirty and small. Ocean view? Uh. No. Our unit faced the parking lot. There were slugs in the shower and two fewer beds than advertised.

Guess what? It was 30 years ago and hubby and I still laugh when we remember the vacation when we had to sleep under the kitchen table.

FAQ: Tips for Renting a Beach House

When is the best time to rent a beach house for summer vacation?

My best tip is to rent your beach house when you start wearing sweaters. You’ll find the best selection in popular destinations in the fall — often as early as October . If you wait too long, the most desirable houses may already be reserved. It’s still possible to find a rental later, but you’ll have fewer options.

Is renting a beach house cheaper than staying in a hotel?

You may find that renting a beach house is often cheaper than booking multiple hotel rooms . A house allows everyone to stay together and includes a kitchen, which makes it easy to prepare breakfasts and pack lunches for the beach. Those savings can add up quickly during a weeklong vacation.

Should you rent a beach house through a real estate agent or directly from the owner?

Both options can work, but experienced rental agents often help match families with the right property . Agents understand the local area and can recommend homes that fit your needs. Renting directly from an owner may sometimes save money, but you may miss helpful guidance about the property and neighborhood.

What should families look for in a beach house rental listing?

Don’t rely on photos alone. When evaluating listings, check the map to confirm how close the house is to the beach, grocery stores and restaurants . Read reviews carefully for comments about noise, cleanliness or unresponsive owners and double-check that the number of beds matches the size of your group.

How can families save money on a beach house rental?

When the kids were toddlers, I loved traveling in the off-season for less crowds and cheaper rental rates. Now that my littles are big, we’re taking advantage of shoulder season again, at least until the grandbabies hit school age.

Read More:

Cathy Bennett Kopf serves as the Daily Editor of SheBuysTravel, reporting to Editor-in-Chief Cindy Richards. She began travel writing after serving as the unofficial (and unpaid) vacation coordinator for hundreds of family and friend trips. She launched her blog, The Open Suitcase, in 2012 and joined the SBT (formerly TravelingMom) team in 2016. A lifelong resident of New York, Cathy currently resides in the scenic Hudson River Valley. She’s a member of the Society of American Travel Writers, the International Travel Writers Alliance and TravMedia.
Read full bio

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *